A proposal to redevelop Forestville RSL into a new clubhouse with multi-storey retirement living units is under review, drawing mixed responses from the community.
Background: Redevelopment Plans at Forestville RSL
Forestville RSL has submitted a $77 million development application (DA2024/1303) proposing the demolition of existing facilities on Melwood Avenue to build a new clubhouse beneath 55 independent living units for retirees. The plan includes replacing the bowling greens with a clubhouse topped by 16 retirement units, alongside three separate three-storey retirement buildings where the current main club stands.
The Sydney North Planning Panel is now considering the proposal, given its size and community significance. The club has stated the redevelopment aims to future-proof operations and reduce reliance on gaming revenue.
Community Concerns and Legal Framework
Concerns have been raised by some residents and members regarding the scale and purpose of the redevelopment. A petition started by Dominic Alecci argues the development would transform the club into a suburb-dominating retirement village, reducing community-friendly spaces in favour of a smaller RSL facility with a strong focus on gaming.
Questions have also been raised about the process, with claims that members were not provided an opportunity to review or vote on the plans before submission to NBC. Under the NSW Registered Clubs Act 1976 No. 31, section 41E, any disposal of club property must be approved by a majority of votes at a general meeting.
Forestville RSL CEO Ian Thomson stated that a member vote would occur after development application approval, following legal advice. The club maintains it has consistently communicated its strategic direction to members.
Community Sentiment: Petition Campaign Gains Support
A community-led petition against the redevelopment has gained traction, recording 903 signatures to date. Petitioners argue that the proposed development would eliminate popular family outdoor areas and increase the proportion of poker machine space within the new club design.
They have also expressed concerns about the retirement complex overlooking nearby facilities used by young children. The Northern Beaches Design & Sustainability Advisory Panel reportedly called for a complete redesign, though the club management continues to pursue the original application.
Next Steps for the Forestville RSL Project
Forestville RSL has indicated that it continues to meet with authorities to refine the project, addressing non-compliance issues identified by the NBC. An Annual General Meeting is scheduled on 28 April, where further information sessions for members will occur. The timeline for a formal member vote on the redevelopment has not yet been confirmed.
Published 26-Apr-2025
